blog · ai test · berlin

How ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google pick dentists in Kreuzberg: a dated test

By Mohamed Elazab · Berlin · 10 November 2026

ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google name the Kreuzberg dental practices whose details they can confirm. In our test on 10 November 2026, the practices that state their languages, new-patient policy and Saturday hours in plain text were named and quoted. Practices that leave those facts out were skipped or flagged with “call first”.

This post covers one test: 8 customer questions, asked in English and German, in three AI tools, signed out. Below are the numbers, the exact phrases the tools used to justify their picks, and a short checklist for any Berlin clinic or practice that wants to be on the list. We name no practice. This is about how the tools choose, not about who is the best dentist.

How did we run the test?

We asked 8 fixed questions about dentists in Kreuzberg, once in English and once in German, in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google, signed out, on 10 November 2026 between about 14:20 and 14:37 Berlin time. That is 48 queries. 45 got an answer; 3 Perplexity queries hit a sign-up wall.

The questions were the ones real patients type:

#EnglishGerman
1best dentist in Kreuzbergbester Zahnarzt in Kreuzberg
2English-speaking dentist in Kreuzberg, Berlinenglischsprachiger Zahnarzt in Berlin Kreuzberg
3Can you recommend a dentist near Kreuzberg that takes new patients?… der neue Patienten annimmt?
4dentist Kreuzberg open on SaturdayZahnarzt Kreuzberg samstags geöffnet
5Which dentist in Berlin has the best reviews?Welcher Zahnarzt in Berlin hat die besten Bewertungen?
6dentist in Kreuzberg for expatsZahnarzt in Kreuzberg für Expats
7How do I choose a good dentist in Berlin?Wie finde ich einen guten Zahnarzt in Berlin?
8dentist near me Kreuzberg BerlinZahnarzt in meiner Nähe Kreuzberg Berlin

We fixed the list before seeing any answer and will reuse it for other niches, so results can be compared. We saved the text of each answer with its link and time, plus screenshots. The browser had no account and no history. Google placed the session in Kreuzberg by itself.

Which practices did the AI tools name?

A small group took most of the mentions. Across 45 answers, more than 20 different practices in and around Kreuzberg were named. One practice appeared in more than half of the answers (26 of 45), the next in 20. Several appeared only once or twice, mostly for one narrow question such as Saturday hours.

What the tools showed per engine:

EngineAnsweredWhat the answers showed
ChatGPT16 of 16Star rating and review count in the text of 11 answers (3 more showed ratings on the map only), then a follow-up question about treatment and insurance
Perplexity13 of 16A source link on almost every row: the practice’s own site, Doctolib, Jameda or a Berlin dental directory
Google16 of 16An AI Overview on every query, and a three-practice map pack on most local questions

Google showed an AI Overview for all 16 queries, including the German ones (“Übersicht mit KI”). For a search like “best dentist in Kreuzberg”, that box is now the first organic thing a patient reads. On that query it sat below four sponsored places and three text ads.

Why did some practices get picked over others?

The deciding factor was confirmable detail. When a practice’s website or listing stated a fact in plain words, the AI repeated it as the reason to choose that practice. When the fact was missing, the tool hedged or picked someone else. The star rating decided who was considered, not who came first.

Three examples, quoted from the answers:

  • Language. ChatGPT, asked in German for an English-speaking dentist, picked two practices because “Beide bestätigen ausdrücklich auf ihrer Website, dass sie englischsprachige Patienten betreuen” (both state explicitly on their website that they treat English-speaking patients). Perplexity picked its first choice because the practice’s own site says, in one sentence, that its dentists speak English.
  • New patients. ChatGPT labelled one practice “Confirmed: accepts new patients” and wrote of a higher-rated one: “New-patient availability isn’t explicitly confirmed online, so I’d call first.” Google’s AI Overview, in English and in German, led with a practice whose FAQ answers “Are you accepting new patients?” with “Yes”.
  • Opening hours. For Saturday questions, the tools listed hours word for word from Google Business Profiles and directories. ChatGPT said its hours came “laut aktuellen Verzeichnissen” (from current directories). A practice with only 18 Google reviews made Google’s map pack for both Saturday queries because its Saturday hours were filled in.

Do Google reviews still matter for AI answers?

Yes, but as a filter, not as the final ranking. Most ChatGPT answers showed a rating and review count. Most practices named for Kreuzberg-specific questions were rated 4.2 to 5.0, and the most-named one 4.8 with about 150 reviews, not the one with a perfect 5.0. A practice rated 3.7 still made two Saturday lists, because its Saturday hours were published.

Perplexity said it directly: “a 4.9 rating from 95 reviews is not necessarily more reliable than 4.8 from 525.” For the open question “Which dentist in Berlin has the best reviews?”, the three tools gave three different top-three lists, and none of them was in Kreuzberg. Review volume and recency count alongside the average.

This matches what Google says about its own local results. Its tips to improve your local ranking say local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and popularity, and that reviews and links to your business feed into how well known a place is. A rating gets you into the group of candidates. The details on your site and profile decide whether the AI can say why it picked you.

Where do ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google get their information?

From three kinds of source: the practice’s own website, its Google Business Profile, and the booking and review platforms patients already use. In our 45 answers the tools named Doctolib, Jameda, the KZV Berlin dentist search, Das Telefonbuch, several Berlin dental directories, an expat guide and Reddit threads.

Each engine leaned on different sources:

  • ChatGPT showed Google-style ratings and review counts in most answers, cited a German expert-ranking site for “best reviews”, and took Saturday hours from phone-book listings.
  • Perplexity cited the practice’s own website for most claims, then Doctolib for booking details and new-patient slots, then dental directories.
  • Google blended its own Business Profile data (hours, accessibility and LGBTQ+-friendly attributes) with text from the practice’s site, such as which dentist on the team speaks which language.

Google states there is no special setup for this. Its page on AI features and your website says there are “no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode”. The same basics apply, but the AI layer only repeats what it can find and confirm.

Does it matter whether patients ask in English or German?

Less than expected. The same core group of practices came up in both languages, and the reasons given were the same: languages spoken, new-patient status, hours. In both languages the tools also asked about insurance (public, private or self-pay) as a follow-up.

For Berlin clinics with international patients this has a practical point: the English-speaking question is asked in German too. “Englischsprachiger Zahnarzt” produced the same top picks as “English-speaking dentist”, though the rest of the list varied. A practice that states its languages clearly is covered in both. The KZV Berlin Zahnarztsuche, which both Perplexity and Google pointed patients to, also lets them filter dentists by foreign language, so that field is worth keeping current.

What should a Berlin clinic fix first?

Make the facts patients ask about easy to find and easy to quote. Start with the five below. They come straight from the reasons the AI tools gave in this test, and none of them needs a new website.

  1. State your languages in a sentence on the homepage and team page, per person if it differs: “Dr. X treats in English, German and Turkish.” Add the same to your Google Business Profile description and booking profiles.
  2. Answer “Are you taking new patients?” in a short FAQ, with the date you last updated it. Change it when the answer changes.
  3. Fill in every set of hours. Regular, Saturday and special hours in your Google Business Profile (Google’s guide to editing your profile covers main, special and more hours), and the same hours on Doctolib, Jameda and phone-book listings.
  4. Set the profile attributes that apply: wheelchair access, online appointments, languages. Google’s AI Overview repeated these attributes.
  5. Keep reviews coming in steadily and reply to them. Volume and recency mattered more than a perfect average.

Then check that your name, address and hours match on your site, your profile and the booking platforms. The tools cross-check, and a mismatch is a reason to pick someone else.

How can you test your own practice?

Run the same kind of test once a month. Open ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google in a private window, ask the 8 questions your patients ask in English and German, and save each answer with the date. Count how often you are named, and read the reason the tool gives for each pick.

Keep the questions fixed so the results stay comparable, and note what changed on your site or profile in between. In our experience the reasons the tools give are the most useful part of the answer: they tell you which missing sentence cost you the slot. For one client of ours, an HVAC company in Canada, ChatGPT named the client in 5 of 9 local customer questions on 29 September 2026 and in 7 of 9 on 1 November 2026.

For more on how AI tools choose local businesses in Berlin, see how to get your Berlin business recommended by ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews.

A week later I ran the same 16 questions for physiotherapists in Mitte: what ChatGPT and Google check first for an English-speaking physio.

What are the limits of this test?

This is one run on one day, in one signed-out browser, so treat it as a snapshot. AI answers change from run to run: even review counts shifted between our English and German runs a few minutes apart. Star ratings are a snapshot of opinion, not a measure of treatment quality.

We also could not see everything. Three Perplexity queries hit a sign-up wall, and we did not test logged-in or mobile app versions, which can use location and history. The pattern was consistent across all three tools, though, and it matches what Google publishes about local results.

FAQ

Does ChatGPT use Google reviews to recommend dentists?

In our test, most ChatGPT answers showed star ratings and review counts in the format of Google reviews, and for one question it cited a ranking “based on public Google reviews”. Reviews decided which practices were considered. The final pick came down to what the practice’s own site and listings confirmed.

Do Google Ads put a practice into the AI Overview?

Not by itself, in our test. On “best dentist in Kreuzberg”, Google showed four sponsored places and three text ads above the AI Overview. One advertiser was also first in the AI Overview, with details from its profile and website; another advertiser was not in it at all.

Why does ChatGPT say “call first” about some practices?

Because it could not confirm the fact online. When asked for a dentist taking new patients, ChatGPT marked practices that state it as “Confirmed” and told the user to call the others first. A short, dated line on your website settles the question for the AI and for patients.

How often should a Berlin clinic check its AI visibility?

Monthly is enough for most practices. Use the same fixed questions each time, in English and German, signed out, and save the answers with the date. Check again after any change to your hours, team, languages or new-patient status, since those are the facts the tools quoted.

Get the same check for your practice

We run this test for Berlin businesses as part of local SEO for Berlin businesses: your niche, your district, questions asked in English and German, with the reasons each tool gave and the fixes in order. If you run a clinic or practice in Berlin, ask for the free check on that page.

free local check

Want to know what AI says about your business?

Send your website. Within 48 hours you get your Google Maps and AI-answer snapshot and the three fixes that matter most. Free, in English, no obligation. Or email info@searchgeopro.com.

I reply within one business day. Your details are never shared.